Sister vs. Sister "Belly-Off"

ppfd

As we've seen, there are a lot of female celebs with sisters who are also celebs in their own right. Which belly/bellybutton of these gals do you prefer (feel free to add any I might've missed)?

Haylie/Hilary Duff - Haylie for me

Kate/Rooney Mara - Kate (though I think Rooney is cuter)

Emily/Zooey Deschanel - we don't have much to go on for Emily, but Zooey nonetheless

Dakota/Elle Fanning - Elle is starting to win me over

Jessica/Ashlee Simpson - Jessica by far

Rosanna/Patricia Arquette - Patricia by far

Vanessa/Stella Hudgens - close, but, because Stella has never had hers pierced, she wins :P

Kaili/Dani/Bella Thorne - Dani for now... but Bella could usurp her in a couple of years

Kate/Pippa Middleton - Pippa (though I think Kate is better-looking)

Kendall/Kylie Jenner - Kylie by far (sorry, MikeB)

**I suppose we could do mother/daughter combos as well:**

Susan Sarandon/Eva Amurri Martino - too close to call, but Susan wins for me

Goldie Hawn/Kate Hudson - Goldie (I've honestly never cared for Kate)

Melanie Griffith/Dakota Johnson - Dakota

Demi Moore/Rumer Willis - Demi by far

Lea Thompson/Zoey Deutch - Lea

Heather Locklear/Ava Sambora - Heather

**Or THREE generations:**

Priscilla Presley/Lisa Marie Presley/Riley Keough - Priscilla

**Or even aunts/nieces ;D:**

Julia/Emma Roberts - Emma

Jane/Bridget Fonda - Bridget

MikeBrooklyn

Haylie/Hilary Duff - Neither. Haylie is a butterface in my opinion and I need to see a better view of Hilary post-baby bellybutton.

Kate/Rooney Mara - Kate. Don't find Rooney the least bit attractive (but then again, I only know her from Girl with the Dragon Tattoo, and she was made to look ugly in that.)

Emily/Zooey Deschanel - Zooey, even if she is a Katy Perry clone, and you can't recognized her without her hair on her forehead.

Dakota/Elle Fanning - Elle has been much more giving to us.

Jessica/Ashlee Simpson - Couldn't care less about either of them, but Jessica has been good to us, so I'll go with her.

Rosanna/Patricia Arquette - I've barely seen Rosanna in anything other than Pulp Fiction, so Patrica (who was better in True Romance anyway).

Vanessa/Stella Hudgens - Vanessa is hotter, but like ppfd said, Stella is without a ring. Tie.

Kaili/Dani/Bella Thorne - Bella is the most mainstream, and the most navel friendly, so her.

Kate/Pippa Middleton - Kate is someone's wife and mother, so I'll go with the single Pippa.

Kendall/Kylie Jenner - As far as I'm concerned, one is a hottie with a beautifully unique bellybutton, and the other is a troll with a generic innie. No contest. Kendall.

**I suppose we could do mother/daughter combos as well:**

Susan Sarandon/Eva Amurri Martino - Eva has been good to us during her short career.

Goldie Hawn/Kate Hudson - Kate, based solely on her post baby outie.

Melanie Griffith/Dakota Johnson - Neither.

Demi Moore/Rumer Willis - Demi, because Rumer inherited her father's chin.

Lea Thompson/Zoey Deutch - I grew up in the 80s, so Lea.

Heather Locklear/Ava Sambora - Couldn't care less about Ava, so Heather.

I guess in ten years we can do Katie Holmes vs. Suri Cruise and/or Angelina Jolie vs. Shiloh Jolie-Pitt.

**Or THREE generations:**

Priscilla Presley/Lisa Marie Presley/Riley Keough - Priscilla, based on her bellybutton alone.

**Or even aunts/nieces:**

Julia/Emma Roberts - Emma for her body, but I'd rather see Julia acting.

Jane/Bridget Fonda - Jane, back when she was young and hot, although Bridget was good in Jackie Brown.

ppfd

One I forgot:

Jennifer/Meg Tilly - Jennifer by far (though Meg is the one with whom I'd want to hang out)

rom

There is also the trio of Annalynne McCord and her sisters Angel and Rachel. My vote in that line-up is Annalynne!

Triple play!

Also, let's give twins their due: Liz and Jean Sagal. Take your pick, both were wonderful.

MikeBrooklyn

They Tilly Sisters: Meg was hotter in my opinion, although Jennifer was a bigger success.

McCord Sisters: AnnaLynne #1, then Rachel at #2, and Angel at #3.

And I'll throw in the Olsen Sisters: Elizabeth at #1, and Mary-Kate and Ashley, no one cares about any more.

00swatcher

MikeBrooklyn

And I’ll throw in the Olsen Sisters: Elizabeth at #1, and Mary-Kate and Ashley, no one cares about any more.

These sisters have a small gap between ages, but they feel like they are from different eras.

Sisters:

Melissa Joan Hart/Emily Hart- Melissa Joan Hart has exposed a lot of belly, both for modeling and for Sabrina: The Teenage Witch. On the other hand, there is not much info on Emily Hart let alone photos of her belly.

ppfd

There's also Britney/Jamie Lynn Spears, BeyoncÃ©/Solange Knowles, and Kylie/Dannii Minogue (the latter of each don't have threads yet).

MikeBrooklyn

There's also Britney/Jamie Lynn Spears, BeyoncÃ©/Solange Knowles, and Kylie/Dannii Minogue (the latter of each don't have threads yet).

Ummm ... yeah, I don't care about any of those sisterly pairings. Unless you count Beyonce Knowles' father adopting Kelly Rowland, in which case, I choose Kelly Rowland.

jillymayr

wow you just compared ashley and jessica - they aren't even in the same league at all

ppfd

There's also Britney/Jamie Lynn Spears, BeyoncÃ©/Solange Knowles, and Kylie/Dannii Minogue (the latter of each don't have threads yet).

Ummm ... yeah, I don't care about any of those sisterly pairings. Unless you count Beyonce Knowles' father adopting Kelly Rowland, in which case, I choose Kelly Rowland.

I don't, either (except maybe Kylie and Dannii), but they're nonetheless celebrity sisters. At least I didn't mention the Kardashians. :P

MikeBrooklyn

There's also Britney/Jamie Lynn Spears, BeyoncÃ©/Solange Knowles, and Kylie/Dannii Minogue (the latter of each don't have threads yet).

Ummm ... yeah, I don't care about any of those sisterly pairings. Unless you count Beyonce Knowles' father adopting Kelly Rowland, in which case, I choose Kelly Rowland.

I don't, either (except maybe Kylie and Dannii), but they're nonetheless celebrity sisters. At least I didn't mention the Kardashians. :P

Eww, the Kardashians? I would still go with Kendall, even though she's a Jenner.

ppfd

Half sisters Carrie/Joely Fisher could also be added, I suppose. Obviously Carrie wins on the strength of Slave Leia alone (and the fact that Joely has given us very little belly exposure)... though Joely has aged significantly better so far.

MikeBrooklyn

Half sisters Carrie/Joely Fisher could also be added, I suppose. Obviously Carrie wins on the strength of Slave Leia alone (and the fact that Joely has given us very little belly exposure)... though Joely has aged significantly better so far.

Yeah, Leia in the metal bikini trumps all.

ppfd

A few more to add:

Kylie/Dannii Minogue - too close to call

Poppy/Cara Delevingne - Poppy

Vanessa/Laura Marano - too close to call

Mother/daughter:

Kim Basinger/Ireland Baldwin - definitely Kim

Three generations:

Tippi Hedren/Melanie Griffith/Dakota Johnson - still Dakota

MikeBrooklyn

A few more to add:

1. Kylie/Dannii Minogue - too close to call

2. Poppy/Cara Delevingne - Poppy

3. Vanessa/Laura Marano - too close to call

Mother/daughter:

4. Kim Basinger/Ireland Baldwin - definitely Kim

Three generations:

5. Tippi Hedren/Melanie Griffith/Dakota Johnson - still Dakota

1. Kylie, really no contest in my opinion, she always brought the sex appeal more.

2. While Poppy is without body art, Cara has the prettier face and more interesting bellybutton.

3. They might as well be twins, so this ends in a draw.

4, Bellybutton wise, Kim wins for having the iconic 9 and 1/2 Weeks ice cube to the bellybutton scene and for not having

a navel ring. If we're talking overall looks and face, Ireland wins.

5. I always thought Tippi was the hottest Hitchcock actress, so she wins. I never found Melanie attractive and Dakota does nothing for me.

ppfd

5. I always thought Tippi was the hottest Hitchcock actress, so she wins. I never found Melanie attractive and Dakota does nothing for me.

While I consider Tippi the best-looking of the 3 (back in her youth, at least), her scant belly offerings kind of make Dakota the default winner for me. While I did think Melanie was kinda cute in her youth, her airheadedness has turned me off. :P

ppfd

Vera/Taissa Farmiga - as with the Hudgens sisters, the default winner here is the one without the piercing; Vera in this case.

MikeBrooklyn

Vera/Taissa Farmiga - as with the Hudgens sisters, the default winner here is the one without the piercing; Vera in this case.

Agreed!

ppfd

A couple more Mother/Daughter combos:

Christie Brinkley/Alexa Ray Joel: Christie for sure

Robin Wright/Dylan Penn: Dylan (though I'd have loved to have seen Robin's pre-pregnancy bellybutton :-\)

MikeBrooklyn

A couple more Mother/Daughter combos:

Christie Brinkley/Alexa Ray Joel: Christie for sure

Robin Wright/Dylan Penn: Dylan (though I'd have loved to have seen Robin's pre-pregnancy bellybutton :-\)

Christie/Alexa: Neither do anything for me.

Robin/Dylan: Robin for the bellybutton, Dylan for everything else.

ppfd

Spencer/Greer Grammer (technically half-sisters, Ã la Carrie/Joely Fisher) - Spencer, mostly because Greer appears to have had hers pierced at some point

Venus/Serena Williams - six of one, half a dozen of the other :P